Jump to content

Network Vision/LTE - New York City Market


Ace41690

Recommended Posts

I got a chance to try out T-Mobile's network in here in the city yesterday. While going around Manhattan, signal strength varied from place to place. In Chelsea, Sprint has a stronger signal in general. When I went uptown to around 72nd Street, T-Mobile had the stronger signal. 

 

One thing that I noticed for certain was that indoors, Sprint's network was way stronger. In Chelsea on the 18th floor of a building that I was in, Sprint had a stronger signal than T-Mobile. As I walked further into the building I watched my Sprint phone go down to -105dbm signal on Band 26. Meanwhile, the T-Mobile device dropped to HSPA+ very quickly and then further to EDGE while my device stayed on LTE. 

 

When I went to La Dinastia on 72nd Street, my phone had full signal on LTE outside but quickly dropped to two bars of EVDO. The T-Mobile phone managed to hold on to LTE inside the restaurant with a pretty good signal. The seemed more of the exception rather than the rule. Back home in Brooklyn, my phone managed to have a better signal on Sprint than T-Mobile indoors, but outdoors the opposite is true.

 

It was interesting being able to compare the two for myself.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Spent the day in Brooklyn today.

 

3G. 3G everywhere. I was not impressed.

 

(I was also not impressed that Brooklyn seems lacking in Billiards Halls and Bowling Alleys, WTF do people see in that place?)

First, where on Brooklyn were you? Second, the entirety of NYC is lacking in billiards halls and bowling alleys. Those activities aren't very popular here.

 

If you're in Brooklyn, go to the movies, go shopping, go to a restaurant, go to Prospect Park, the Brooklyn Museum, BAM (Brooklyn Academy of Music). They're all super fun and tons more interesting than any bowling alley.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Spent the day in Brooklyn today.

 

3G. 3G everywhere. I was not impressed.

 

(I was also not impressed that Brooklyn seems lacking in Billiards Halls and Bowling Alleys, WTF do people see in that place?)

What part of BK we're you in?

 

I never drop to 3G when I'm in BK.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

First, where on Brooklyn were you? Second, the entirety of NYC is lacking in billiards halls and bowling alleys. Those activities aren't very popular here.

 

If you're in Brooklyn, go to the movies, go shopping, go to a restaurant, go to Prospect Park, the Brooklyn Museum, BAM (Brooklyn Academy of Music). They're all super fun and tons more interesting than any bowling alley.

 

I went ice skating in Prospect Park and then had lunch by the Borough Hall. 3Gs all around.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just got full LTE near my school in Floral Park. Took them long enough lol.

 

B41

48ping

8 Down

13 up

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I went ice skating in Prospect Park and then had lunch by the Borough Hall. 3Gs all around.

 

That's weird considering both places have been covered in LTE for a pretty long time. I was by Prospect Park over Spring Break and didn't drop LTE once. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What folks do not realize is that if their device is in an active data session, it will not hand up to LTE if it is on 3G. Sometimes I see my phone sitting on 3G for a while, because something is sending in the background. Once it idles, I see LTE.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What folks do not realize is that if their device is in an active data session, it will not hand up to LTE if it is on 3G. Sometimes I see my phone sitting on 3G for a while, because something is sending in the background. Once it idles, I see LTE.

That was my thought exactly.
  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I went ice skating in Prospect Park and then had lunch by the Borough Hall. 3Gs all around.

 

Spent the day in Brooklyn today.

 

3G. 3G everywhere. I was not impressed.

 

Out of curiosity, are you still using an original single-band GS4?

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What folks do not realize is that if their device is in an active data session, it will not hand up to LTE if it is on 3G.

 

I would assume getting on and off the subway would help. It did not

 

 

Out of curiosity, are you still using an original single-band GS4?

 

Yes I am, no 800 LTE for me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would assume getting on and off the subway would help. It did not

 

 

 

Yes I am, no 800 LTE for me.

Getting on and off the subway definitely would not help...

 

And, not having a tri-band device definitely does not help.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Getting on and off the subway definitely would not help...

 

And, not having a tri-band device definitely does not help.

 

What do you mean, doesn't losing the signal completely mean my phone will try for 4G when I get to my destination?

 

No, it doesn't but I'm 6 months away from my upgrade.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What do you mean, doesn't losing the signal completely mean my phone will try for 4G when I get to my destination?

 

No, it doesn't but I'm 6 months away from my upgrade.

What phone do you plan on upgrading to?

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What do you mean, doesn't losing the signal completely mean my phone will try for 4G when I get to my destination?

 

No, it doesn't but I'm 6 months away from my upgrade.

 

No it does not. It goes to the last available signal first. Only an airplane mode toggle, or shutting off the mobile radio completely causes a rescan of all technologies, starting with LTE.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey there guys.  I'm new to Sprint and work downtown near Wall Street.

 

Just started using my new iPhone 6, and was horrified at how bad the "Spark LTE" performance was in the Financial District.

 

First, I checked to make sure I was on Band 41, and Fieldtest confirmed that indeed I was, with 20 MHz of juicy bandwidth (I wanted to post a screenshot but I cannot figure out how).  It says I'm on Band 41, with a DL freq of 39991 and signal strength of -111 (which seems a little wimpy).

 

Then I ran a speed test on a local server using Spark LTE.  I got horrific latency, poor download speeds, and horrific upload speed... I literally cannot send an MMS message with LTE on.  A 144 ms ping, a 2.59 mbps average download time, and 0.15 mbps upload (not a typo!)

 

Testing EVDO for comparison, performance is generally better with the LTE radio turned off!  I got a 61 ms ping, 0.4 mbps download (not great) and 0.85 mbps upload (fast enough to send picture messages at least).

 

Is this typical for Sprint in downtown NYC?  If so, the phone is going back today and I'm off to T-Mobile.  Checking Sprint's map, it promises full Sprint Spark, and a few weeks ago when I checked, this area was "Spark Turbo" certified... this seems awfully misleading if "Spark Turbo" is providing only this level of performance in the center of the global finance industry.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey there guys.  I'm new to Sprint and work downtown near Wall Street.

 

Just started using my new iPhone 6, and was horrified at how bad the "Spark LTE" performance was in the Financial District.

 

First, I checked to make sure I was on Band 41, and Fieldtest confirmed that indeed I was, with 20 MHz of juicy bandwidth (I wanted to post a screenshot but I cannot figure out how).  It says I'm on Band 41, with a DL freq of 39991 and signal strength of -111 (which seems a little wimpy).

 

Then I ran a speed test on a local server using Spark LTE.  I got horrific latency, poor download speeds, and horrific upload speed... I literally cannot send an MMS message with LTE on.  A 144 ms ping, a 2.59 mbps average download time, and 0.15 mbps upload (not a typo!)

 

Testing EVDO for comparison, performance is generally better with the LTE radio turned off!  I got a 61 ms ping, 0.4 mbps download (not great) and 0.85 mbps upload (fast enough to send picture messages at least).

 

Is this typical for Sprint in downtown NYC?  If so, the phone is going back today and I'm off to T-Mobile.  Checking Sprint's map, it promises full Sprint Spark, and a few weeks ago when I checked, this area was "Spark Turbo" certified... this seems awfully misleading if "Spark Turbo" is providing only this level of performance in the center of the global finance industry.

No, Sprint is excellent in NYC, but it all depends on location.

 

This is more typical here, these are tests in Uptown/Midtown Manhattan, Bronx and Queens done today.

 

https://onedrive.live.com/?cid=b94c49085b302a13&id=B94C49085B302A13%215312&action=Share&v=3

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hard to see how they can be "excellent" in NYC if they're not functioning in Wall Street.  Wall Street isn't some minor far-flung area.

 

I'll do some more speed tests tonight -- I'm going to be dining in the Seaport and doing some shopping near the WTC.  Will report back with my findings.

 

PS -- Didn't think of posting photos from my OneDrive.  Smart idea.  I'll post some screencaps the same way.

Edited by NewYorkCityBloke
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hard to see how they can be "excellent" in NYC if they're not functioning in Wall Street.  Wall Street isn't some minor far-flung area.

 

I'll do some more speed tests tonight -- I'm going to be dining in the Seaport and doing some shopping near the WTC.  Will report back with my findings.

Wall Street was a sore spot since Hurricane Sandy. It made it extremely difficult for Sprint to get proper backhaul support (Since all the other carriers already had high speed backhaul before Sandy) Sprint was by far the last to have access to it. Until very recently, so a lot of optimization and build out is yet to be completed down there. 

 

Also, Sprint is in the process of adding additional capacity to B41, expect  faster speeds even at a very very weak signal soon.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hmmmm... any idea on when the optimizations will be completed?  I don't want to leave, but I can't function with high-latency, high jitter low-speed data... :(

My suggestion is give it a go for a few more days, and see how it all works out for you. We don't expect all these things to happen overnight, so if your expecting to see things work 100% better tomorrow its probably not going to happen.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • large.unreadcontent.png.6ef00db54e758d06

  • gallery_1_23_9202.png

  • Similar Content

  • Posts

    • From WSJ which is paywalled but they're reporting that T-Mobile and Verizon are working on a joint deal to buy and split up U.S. Cellular. https://www.wsj.com/business/telecom/t-mobile-verizon-in-talks-to-carve-up-u-s-cellular-46d1e5e6?st=qwngrnh4s3bcr76 — — — — —  Summary from a user in the Reddit thread:  
    • So, in summary, here are the options I tested: T-Mobile intl roaming - LTE on SoftBank, routes back to the US (~220ms to 4.2.2.4) IIJ physical SIM - LTE on NTT, local routing Airalo - LTE on SoftBank and KDDI (seems to prefer SoftBank), routed through Singapore (SingTel) Ubigi - 5G on NTT, routed through Singapore (Transatel) US Mobile East Asia roaming - 5G on SoftBank, routed through Singapore (Club SIM) Saily - 5G on NTT, routed through Hong Kong (Truphone)...seems to be poorer routing my1010 - LTE on SoftBank and KDDI (seems to prefer KDDI), routed through Taiwan (Chunghwa Telecom) I wouldn't buy up on the T-Mobile international roaming, but it's a solid fallback. If you have the US Mobile roaming eSIM that's a great option. Otherwise Ubigi, Airalo, or my1010 are all solid options, so get whatever's cheapest. I wouldn't bother trying to find a physical SIM from IIJ...the Japanese IP is nice but there's enough WiFi that you can get a Japanese IP enough for whatever you need, and eSIM flexibility is great (IIJ as eSIM but seems a bit more involved to get it to work).
    • So, the rural part of the journey still has cell service for nearly all the way, usually on B18/19/8 (depending on whether we're talking about KDDI/NTT/SoftBank). I think I saw a bit of B28 and even n28 early on in the trip, though that faded out after a bit. Once we got to where we were going though, KDDI had enough B41 to pull 150+ Mbps, while NTT and SoftBank had B1/B3 IIRC. Cell service was likewise generally fine from Kawaguchiko Station to Tokyo on the express bus to Shinjuku Station, though there were some cases where only low-band LTE was available and capacity seemed to struggle. I also figured out what I was seeing with SoftBank on 40 MHz vs. 100 MHz n77: the 40 MHz blocks are actually inside the n78 band class, but SoftBank advertises them as n77, probably to facilitate NR CA. My phone likely preferred the 40 MHz slices as they're *much* lower-frequency, ~3.4 GHz rather than ~3.9, though of course I did see the 100 MHz slice being used rather often. By contrast, when I got NR on NTT it was either n28 10x10 or, more often, 100 MHz n78. As usual, EMEA bands on my S24 don't CA, so any data speeds I saw were the result of either one LTE carrier or one LTE carrier plus one NR carrier...except for B41 LTE. KDDI seems to have more B41 bandwidth live at this point, so my1010 or Airalo works well for this, and honestly while SoftBank and NTT 5G (in descending order of availability) have 5G that's readily available it may be diminishing returns, particularly given that I still don't know how to, as someone not from Hong Kong, get an eSIM that runs on SoftBank 5G that isn't the USM "comes for free with the unlimited premium package" roaming eSIM (NTT is easy enough thanks to Ubigi). In other news, I was able to borrow someone's Rakuten eSIM and...got LTE with it. 40 Mbps down, 20 Mbps up, 40ms latency to Tokyo while in Tokyo...which isn't any worse than the Japan-based physical SIMs I had used earlier. But not getting n77 or n257 was disappointing, though I had to test the eSIM from one spot rather than bouncing around the city to find somewhere with better reception. It's currently impossible to get a SIM as a foreigner that runs on Rakuten, so that was the best I could do. Also, I know my phone doesn't have all the LTE and 5G bands needed to take full advantage of Japanese networks. My S24 is missing: B21 (1500 MHz) - NTT B11 (1500 MHz) - KDDI, SoftBank B42 (3500 MHz) - NTT, KDDI, SoftBank n79 (4900 MHz) - NTT Of the above, B42/n79 are available on the latest iPhones, though you lose n257, and I'm guessing you're not going to find B11/B21 on a phone sold outside Japan.
    • T-Mobile acquiring SoniqWave's 2.5 GHz spectrum  Another spectrum speculator down! T-Mobile is acquiring all of their BRS/EBS licenses and their leases. Details are lacking but it looks like T-Mobile might be giving them 3.45GHz in exchange in some of the markets where they're acquiring BRS/EBS to sweeten the deal and stay below the spectrum screen. Hopefully NextWave is at the negotiating table with T-Mobile so NYC can finally get access to the full BRS/EBS band as well.  — — — — — Edit: Turns out this is a spectrum swap where T-Mobile is basically giving them DoD spectrum in a bunch of markets in exchange for all of SoniqWave's BRS/EBS. SoniqWave will likely turn around and sell the DoD spectrum to AT&T whenever the FCC removes the 40MHz cap.
  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...