Jump to content

SignalCheck - Android app to monitor your Wi-Fi/2G/3G/4G LTE/5G-NR signal strengths


mikejeep

Recommended Posts

That is very strange. It is always those three towers that do not report properly? And all 15 are Clearwire sites? It sounds more like a network/site issue than a device issue if that's the case. Or are you possibly only seeing 8T8R sites?

 

-Mike

The 15 are Clear sites some Co located with Sprint. The ones not reporting are in a cluster, in other words next to each other. Maybe the contractor did something wrong since they are all adjacent to each other.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

That is very strange. It is always those three towers that do not report properly? And all 15 are Clearwire sites? It sounds more like a network/site issue than a device issue if that's the case. Or are you possibly only seeing 8T8R sites?

 

-Mike

The 15 are Clear sites some Co located with Sprint. The ones not reporting are in a cluster, in other words next to each other. Maybe the contractor did something wrong since they are all adjacent to each other.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mike - 

 

From your testing/coding of the neighboring cell feature, how confident are you that every signal/PCI that shows up in the neighbor cell list is an actual live signal and the PCI for it is accurate?

 

the reason i'm asking is i have seen quite a few PCI show up in the neighbor cell list that don't match any PCI that we have recorded. I've spent the last 3 weeks driving around re-logging the PCI of the towers in my area to make sure they were accurate and hadn't changed since we first logged them. after doing this i'm still seeing PCI that don't exist in our spreadsheet.

 

for example in this screenshot

Screenshot_2014-11-05-16-32-21.png

PCI 496 is not in our spreadsheet, and not only is it not in our spreadsheet but at the -99 signal its showing any tower that would be close enough to show that signal i've reconfirmed the PCI for.

 

and its not just a one time thing either, i've seen that PCI show back up driving through the same area on a different day.

 

just wanted to get your opinion to see if you thought this was some kind of fluke/bug where i'm seeing signals that don't exist, or if these are actual real signals coming from somewhere that my phone is actually seeing.... and if thats the case where are they coming from since i've confirmed all the sprint PCI....

 

also a side request for the neighbor cell feature, can you add an option to disable using the TAC to decide to show the site note? i only have my area in my DB so any PCI with a site note would be accurate to show.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Could that PCI possibly be from a new site in test mode? Just throwing that out there. I'm not an expert but just a thought I had.

 

Sent from my Note 4.

 

while it could be i highly doubt it is, just for the simple fact that i've seen so many PCI that i don't have recorded there would be a ton of new sites around here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

here are some more to add to the list

 

http://i1102.photobucket.com/albums/g442/bradmoses/signalcheck%20screens/Screenshot_2014-11-07-11-39-47.png

233 PCI i see pop up while i'm at work all the time, in this shot i was right next to the MLK tower and again, all towers around there that could give me a -90 signal i've confirmed the PCI for.

 

http://i1102.photobucket.com/albums/g442/bradmoses/signalcheck%20screens/Screenshot_2014-11-07-11-40-12.png

233 again and also 300 is an unknown PCI, still near the MLK tower but a little further south than the first shot

 

http://i1102.photobucket.com/albums/g442/bradmoses/signalcheck%20screens/Screenshot_2014-11-07-11-58-55.png

was right next to the tower i am connected to in this shot, 38 is not a known PCI with all towers in the area having confirmed PCI

Link to comment
Share on other sites

while it could be i highly doubt it is, just for the simple fact that i've seen so many PCI that i don't have recorded there would be a ton of new sites around here.

Are they showing up in your SCP log?

 

Sent from my SM-N910P using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Are they showing up in your SCP log?

 

Sent from my SM-N910P using Tapatalk

 

nope, i've been running my logging for the past 3 weeks now and i never actually connect to whatever tower, assuming it is an actual signal, it is coming from so there is nothing in the log for those PCI.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

nope, i've been running my logging for the past 3 weeks now and i never actually connect to whatever tower, assuming it is an actual signal, it is coming from so there is nothing in the log for those PCI.

When Mike released the update he mentions clearing your log. Did you follow those instructions? I'm just throwing out ideas as I have no real idea what would cause that unless there is in fact some sort of bug?

 

Sent from my SM-N910P using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When Mike released the update he mentions clearing your log. Did you follow those instructions? I'm just throwing out ideas as I have no real idea what would cause that unless there is in fact some sort of bug?

 

Sent from my SM-N910P using Tapatalk

 

yep did that :) completely cleared my log and DB and reloaded it with just the sites that are in my area that start with 07A (or 07B in the case of B41) i have no clearwire B41 around me so didn't need to worry about that.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wonder if they could be the PCIs for USCC B5 LTE sites? The device is seeing them but can't fully connect yet because the roaming agreement hasn't been finalized?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mike sent you a log. I'm seeing the SCP hang after disabling WiFi and WiFi calling. Display looks like this even though WiFi is off. Persists through airplane mode cycling.

 

uploadfromtaptalk1415393862257.jpg

 

sent from an underwater dust storm with my Sprint S5

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wonder if they could be the PCIs for USCC B5 LTE sites? The device is seeing them but can't fully connect yet because the roaming agreement hasn't been finalized?

 

lol trust me thats were i jumped to initially ;) just trying to rule stuff out first..... but yes, assuming these are real signals, i don't believe they are coming from sprint sites.....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mike sent you a log. I'm seeing the SCP hang after disabling WiFi and WiFi calling. Display looks like this even though WiFi is off. Persists through airplane mode cycling.

 

attachicon.gif uploadfromtaptalk1415393862257.jpg

 

sent from an underwater dust storm with my Sprint S5

I think it's a Samsung problem. I've noticed the same on my Note 4. Take a look at the service bars at the top right. They are shown as blank. The only thing that fixes it for me is a restart.

 

Sent from my Note 4.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wonder if they could be the PCIs for USCC B5 LTE sites? The device is seeing them but can't fully connect yet because the roaming agreement hasn't been finalized?

 

 

lol trust me thats were i jumped to initially ;) just trying to rule stuff out first..... but yes, assuming these are real signals, i don't believe they are coming from sprint sites.....

My thought was a different network, but perhaps a management or testing network.  However, if your device is enabled for a multitude of LTE bands, then the radio could very easily see these other signals.  I remember Digiblur having screenshots of his N5 trying to connect to CSpire, then moving on due to authentication failing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think it's a Samsung problem. I've noticed the same on my Note 4. Take a look at the service bars at the top right. They are shown as blank. The only thing that fixes it for me is a restart.

 

Sent from my Note 4.

 

Well, yes and maybe no, but SCP is hanging on the display, the phone is getting data as you can see it says mobile data active. In my engineering screen it says I have a -118dBm LTE connection on B26 and I can get/send data.  It could very well just be a samsung issue, but I was just following up on my report I sent through SCP. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My thought was a different network, but perhaps a management or testing network.  However, if your device is enabled for a multitude of LTE bands, then the radio could very easily see these other signals.  I remember Digiblur having screenshots of his N5 trying to connect to CSpire, then moving on due to authentication failing.

 

i have a LG G Flex and it only supports B25, B26, and B41. Unless of course like gnoj said its seeing USCC B5 which is a subset of B26.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i have a LG G Flex and it only supports B25, B26, and B41. Unless of course like gnoj said its seeing USCC B5 which is a subset of B26.

 

 

Just to add, i checked a coworkers Nexus 5 and the 233 PCI is showing up on his phone too, so at least its not just mine :D

 

Next step is to find a USCC customer with a B5 LTE Android device and get SCP on that phone ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Next step is to find a USCC customer with a B5 LTE Android device and get SCP on that phone ;)

 

did that! unfortunately it was a Note 2 and signal check won't show the PCI and i could not figure out for the life of me how to get to the engineering screen to try and see the PCI there :(

Link to comment
Share on other sites

did that! unfortunately it was a Note 2 and signal check won't show the PCI and i could not figure out for the life of me how to get to the engineering screen to try and see the PCI there :(

If you know where the nearest USCC sites are, you could try driving up to them to see if the signal strength on the mystery PCI(s) noticeably improve.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you know where the nearest USCC sites are, you could try driving up to them to see if the signal strength on the mystery PCI(s) noticeably improve.

 

i'll try and check that more, the only USCC sites i know about for sure are also sprint sites and from what i can tell the stronger my signal from a sprint site the less neighbor cells i see. Plus i'm not sure if all USCC sites around here would have B5 or not. there is a USCC site right out my window at work up the road about 1/4 of a mile and i'm definitely not seeing anything from that tower. 233 is the only unknown PCI i see while at work and it was strongest near the MLK tower. i believe there is a USCC tower on the broadlawns center thats a block over from the MLK tower though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

From your testing/coding of the neighboring cell feature, how confident are you that every signal/PCI that shows up in the neighbor cell list is an actual live signal and the PCI for it is accurate?

 

the reason i'm asking is i have seen quite a few PCI show up in the neighbor cell list that don't match any PCI that we have recorded.

You guys have been chatty today! I have no reason to believe that the neighbor cells that appear are inaccurate; I see many of these "phantom" PCIs as well, and I have my area fully logged and noted. The PCIs that appear seem to be valid, and the signal strengths look to be reasonable. I have always guessed similar things that others have mentioned; another network on a compatible band, a site in testing, etc. The app is simply showing exactly what Android is reporting to it; there isn't any fancy magic going on behind the scenes for this part of the app. It happens to many people, on many devices, in many markets, so it seems to be by design. Maybe someone with advanced knowledge of how LTE networks operate can chime in with an educated explanation.

 

also a side request for the neighbor cell feature, can you add an option to disable using the TAC to decide to show the site note? i only have my area in my DB so any PCI with a site note would be accurate to show.

That would be a little tricky and very user-specific, but I can try coming up with an option for that. Just a word of caution: even if you've only logged "your area", there is still a chance you have duplicate PCIs -- I can be in range of two sites with the same three PCIs by traveling about 5 miles. I'm never in range of both sites at the same time, but I consider them both my local area. I never noticed the PCIs matched until seeing the (wrong) neighbor cell notes.

 

I'm trying to implement a different way to show neighbor notes based on lat/long coordinates instead of TAC, but it's more challenging than I thought, so it may not be feasible.

 

-Mike

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • large.unreadcontent.png.6ef00db54e758d06

  • gallery_1_23_9202.png

  • Similar Content

  • Posts

    • I've now seen 100 MHz n77 from SoftBank and 100 MHz n78 from NTT. NTT seems to be a bit better south of Osaka, though in some cases it drops down to B19 LTE as some areas around here are pretty rural. SoftBank has n77 around, but it's flakey enough that I switched eSIMs earlier this morning.
    • I'm currently typing this from a bullet train headed from Tokyo to Osaka. Using a roaming eSIM rather than T-Mobile as it's a lot cheaper, but I'll start with T-Mobile's roaming experience. Since I have a business line, I can't add data packs online, so I'm just using the 256 kbps baseline service you get by default. That service runs on Softank 4G. SoftBank has a well-built-out LTE network though, with plenty of B41, falling back to B1/3/8 as needed. 5G roaming from T-Mobile doesn't appear to exist though. I've seen 20+10 MHz B41 when I've looked, generally speaking. WiFi calling works well, and voice calls over LTE work fine too (I forgot to turn WiFi back on after doing some testing, so I expect my bill to be a dollar more next month). I want to say I even got HD voice over the cell network for the VoLTE call I did. I have a bunch of eSIMs and a couple of physical SIMs to try out. I've gotten the eSIMs up and running, but last I checked the physical SIM wasn't working even after activation so I'll run through eSIMs for the moment and update this thread with pSIM info and details on not-Tokyo in the coming days. First off, there's US Mobile's complimentary East Asia eSIM (5GB) that I grabbed before my unlimited plan Stateside expired. That SIM uses SIM Club, routing through Singapore, running on SoftBank LTE and 5G. I've seen 40 MHz n77, as well as 10x10 n28, and have seen download speeds in excess of 200 Mbps with uploads of more than 50 Mbps, though typical speeds are slower. Routing is via Equinix/Packet.net. 5G coverage is rather spotty, but LTE is plenty fast enough; either my phone doesn't want to use the 5G band combos that have more coverage or 5G coverage is just spottier here than in the US (at least on T-Mibile). Latency is as low as 95ms to sites in Singapore (usually closer to 120ms), which is pretty great considering the 3300 mi between Tokyo and Singapore. Next there's Ubigi. It also routes through Singapore via Transatel (despite being owned by NTT), and sites on top of NTT docomo's network. I didn't see NTT 5G in Tokyo when I tested it, but since then I've seen 10x10 n28, and have seen B1/B3/B19 on the LTE side. So far it's not the fastest thing out there, but I'm guessing coverage will be a little better...or maybe not. This was $17 for 10GB. Latency is a bit higher to Singapore, but still under 150ms it seems. Then there's Airalo, which was the cheapest when I bought it at $9 for 10GB. It also routes through Singapore (on Singtel), but on my S24 I have my pick of KDDI (au) or SoftBank. KDDI has extensive B41 coverage and I've seen 20+20 with UL CA. While waiting for the train at HND Terminal 3 (Keikyu line) I hit 250+ Mbps down and 10+ Mbps up...over LTE...with pretty respectable latency numbers (not much above 100ms). This is in adition to supporting SoftBank, also on LTE (my S24 defaulted to KDDI, while my wife's Pixel 8 defaulted to SoftBank and didn't seem to want to connect to KDDI). Of the various carriers mentioned, I'd say this was the best pick, though prices have bumped back up to $18 for the 10GB plan...but it's probably still what I'd pick if I had to pick just one carrier. Then there's Saily, which uses Truphone out of Hong Kong. I haven't used this as much, as I only grabbed 3GB for $7. It runs on NTT but doesn't seem to have 5G access and doesn't seem to have as good speeds. Yes, Hong Kong is way closer to Japan, but latency didn't seem to be any better, at ~150ms. In all cases, I've had reception even in train tunnels and even at high speed on the bullet train, on all three carriers I've tried (I don't think I'll be able to play with a Rakuten SIM, which is rather disappointing). There have been cases where service has degraded, but it looks like you'd have reasonable cell service no matter which of the big three carriers you picked...and since T-Mobile roams on one of them, that's good enough if you're content to buy day passes.
    • https://www.phonearena.com/news/t-mobile-older-rate-plan-prices-june_id157821 We're on Sprint Max for our seven phone/two Apple Watch (with Cellular) family plan... Because it doesn't make sense to switch to anything else, especially if we can't even finance all of our devices. Some of you may recall that T-Mobile suddenly cut our credit limit to $1,500 (which is barely more than one iPhone 15 Pro) with no notice at all. I escalated it to the Office of the CEO and was told to pound sand, even though I have 800+ Credit as a longtime customer and was suddenly being treated as a deadbeat. I ultimately upgraded my three iPhone lines directly through Apple and they're Unlocked. I haven't bothered to check on whether my Credit Limit has updated, but I don't plan on upgrading them through T-Mobile again. I guess we'll find out if "Sprint Max" counts as "older" soon enough.
    • From just under a week ago: https://www.t-mobile.com/news/network/t-mobile-announces-163-million-in-completed-network-upgrades-for-arkansas Progress!
  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...