Jump to content

Official Magic Box discussion thread


lilotimz

Recommended Posts

Rural and cell edge users here with newer home, can confirm all of the Mods advice from one year of intense signal hunting in the new compound.  

A shelf on a wall can be amazing versus next to a window in a newer home. I have been all over our home looking for the best signal for our use; we used a Nexus 5 with cheater radio, Netgear Fuse & 6100d, none of these devices could get a fair signal directly near a window, and all are good performers or had externals. I would carefully put the N5 on the lightswitch in the spare room, got 8mb p/s down once! The Fuse on the cupboard scored 3-5, and the 6100d in the garage got about 4-5 tops after many hours of tuning. 

Gave up on all of that when I realized we could utilize the attic. Now, we ended up running a ton of antennas to get better signal,(blah blah this will stay on topic) we found that area was best for our home, while not having to go outdoors and build a pole and deal with what the neighbors would think of that. A small table or shelf could be set up in an attic, garage, maybe an ancillary or non living area that may be overlooked. I ran an outlet I turn off with the attic light switch and all of my gear is out of the way of the HVAC. My Nexus 6p gets searching in the house, but it gets great WiFi from one LTE radio>modem in the attic or from the other one feeding ethernet to the 6100d in the office. 10 feet higher, quality signal, I don't even have to look at it(though I like to) and it turns off when I leave.

Who knows what that could do for a magic box? I hope to find out soon.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Something is still amiss with my Magic Box.  When I woke up this morning, my phone was connected to it.  I power cycled my phone and now it will not connect to the magic box.  Wife's phone has not ever connected to it.  

 

I got an email last night from Sprint asking if I could verify that it is working correctly, and I replied saying that something was still amiss.  I spent probably over 3 hours trying to troubleshoot this thing with the guy I was working with and it still isnt working correctly, so I rather bluntly just asked if it makes sense at this point to try replacing the unit.  I can not imagine that Sprint's intention was to have these things sporadically working.  

 

Just frustrating. :-/  I've seen it work long enough on my phone that I REALLY want it to work all the time now.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Something is still amiss with my Magic Box.  When I woke up this morning, my phone was connected to it.  I power cycled my phone and now it will not connect to the magic box.  Wife's phone has not ever connected to it. 

What is the relay signal strength and band coming into the box?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Highest I got was 20. I'm thinking of sending it back and get the Airave 3 instead since it's so big for my house for a window.

 

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk

 

You are aware of the technical differences between the two devices??

 

I have the airave, but when I walk out of my house, it pretty much loses it's ability to provide a reliable calling signal ...

And 3G is all you're gonna get...

 

The magic box is LTE... which means data only.

You're not gonna improve you're calling by getting a magic box.

You're not gonna get better data speeds by getting a Airave.

 

Now, the upside to the MB, when sprint goes to VO-LTE, then you'll see the MB helping with calls.

Until that point, you're gonna see calls on CDMA, and data on LTE.

 

The airave is eventually going to become outdated...as the CDMA network begins to be shut-down...

i'd say within 8-10 years is what is estimated for CDMA.

 

Likely, if a merger of some kind occurs between Sprint + Tmo..it could happen sooner..

 

I really don't pay much attention to my Airave anymore.

Sometimes I run it for a couple weeks, sometimes i unplug it and let it sit..

 

I try to leave it unplugged for a few days (so I will know when there is work in the area that could improve my reception)...

 

I hope to see B26 soon in my area...or a 2nd B25 carrier...but with the airave, it's not going to be obvious to me at my house.

 

(I will say this, the MB reaches a LOT farther than the airave. I get nearly 1/2 a mile of LTE around my house...which is really surprising for such a small device)

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What is the relay signal strength and band coming into the box?

 

In its current location:

 

RSRP:       -108 dBm

CINR:          15.7 dB

Frequency:  2648000

Band:           41 High

Status:         Connected

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In its current location:

 

RSRP:       -108 dBm

CINR:          15.7 dB

Frequency:  2648000

Band:           41 High

Status:         Connected

Ok it isn't that then. In weak signal areas the unit is prone to drop the relay and even when it comes back up devices may not connect to it initially. On mine, the first time I left the house it took my phone hours to connect to it when I got back.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ok it isn't that then. In weak signal areas the unit is prone to drop the relay and even when it comes back up devices may not connect to it initially. On mine, the first time I left the house it took my phone hours to connect to it when I got back.

 

Yeah - that is what is so frustrating.  Signal levels are all solid.  :(

 

Guess time will tell what they want to do.  We are leaving home later today to take a long camping trip - a trip in which I intend to take the Magic Box along because it is also in a fringe B25 area on our phones.  Guess this is a good way to test to see if this is somehow caused by the macro donor site.  MB always seems to connect to GPS and Relay super quick, but seems to take a while for 'LTE' to connect on it.  The support dude didn't act like that was out of the ordinary, but I would honestly think that both the GPS and Relay signals would take the longest. :shrug:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah - that is what is so frustrating. Signal levels are all solid. :(

 

Guess time will tell what they want to do. We are leaving home later today to take a long camping trip - a trip in which I intend to take the Magic Box along because it is also in a fringe B25 area on our phones. Guess this is a good way to test to see if this is somehow caused by the macro donor site. MB always seems to connect to GPS and Relay super quick, but seems to take a while for 'LTE' to connect on it. The support dude didn't act like that was out of the ordinary, but I would honestly think that both the GPS and Relay signals would take the longest. :shrug:

The LTE connected portion is indeed the longest. It's been the case since the original model. Perfectly normal.

 

I suspect, as someone else mentioned, that your phone isn't really scanning for neighbors on its own (depends on make and model likely). It's using the LTE neighbors list being pushed by the macros, which currently don't show your MB. After a few days these will auto update to tell devices to also look for your MB, once the MB is fully integrated into the network.

 

Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

You are aware of the technical differences between the two devices??

 

I have the airave, but when I walk out of my house, it pretty much loses it's ability to provide a reliable calling signal ...

And 3G is all you're gonna get...

 

The magic box is LTE... which means data only.

You're not gonna improve you're calling by getting a magic box.

You're not gonna get better data speeds by getting a Airave.

 

Now, the upside to the MB, when sprint goes to VO-LTE, then you'll see the MB helping with calls.

Until that point, you're gonna see calls on CDMA, and data on LTE.

 

The airave is eventually going to become outdated...as the CDMA network begins to be shut-down...

i'd say within 8-10 years is what is estimated for CDMA.

 

Likely, if a merger of some kind occurs between Sprint + Tmo..it could happen sooner..

 

I really don't pay much attention to my Airave anymore.

Sometimes I run it for a couple weeks, sometimes i unplug it and let it sit..

 

I try to leave it unplugged for a few days (so I will know when there is work in the area that could improve my reception)...

 

I hope to see B26 soon in my area...or a 2nd B25 carrier...but with the airave, it's not going to be obvious to me at my house.

 

(I will say this, the MB reaches a LOT farther than the airave. I get nearly 1/2 a mile of LTE around my house...which is really surprising for such a small device)

I think he is referring to the Airave 3 coming out soon which includes LTE.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The LTE connected portion is indeed the longest. It's been the case since the original model. Perfectly normal.

 

I suspect, as someone else mentioned, that your phone isn't really scanning for neighbors on its own (depends on make and model likely). It's using the LTE neighbors list being pushed by the macros, which currently don't show your MB. After a few days these will auto update to tell devices to also look for your MB, once the MB is fully integrated into the network.

 

Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk

Thanks for the added color.  I can at least chew on that as a possible issue.

 

My phone did connect to the MB at some point this morning.  Was out working on our camper and noticed on my phone that I had 5 'bars' (-82 B41) signal out in my yard.  I placed a quick phone call, then hung up.  My phone is now latched back onto the macro tower and not my MB.

 

Really really confused as to how this thing/network/phone is programmed.  I assumed that if I was connected to the magic box, then place a phone call/reboot/cycle airplane mode, the phone would first scan for the last connected system (in this case, the magic box.)  That is apparently wrong.  In this case, for whatever reason, the phone connects to LTE from the macro tower.  I still do not understand at what point my phone decided to switch over to the magic box.  I had already tried a phone reboot as well as cycling airplane mode which I thought would force it to 're-scan' and then grab the Magic Box, but it never grabbed onto it, and still hasn't 30 minutes later.  Makes zero sense to me.  

 

Is anyone with a fully functional magic box able to test the above instance and see what happens?  Ensure you are connected to the Magic Box, then place a phone call, then after the phone call, see how long your phone takes to reconnect to the magic box.  Just wondering if this is common.  :(

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the added color.  I can at least chew on that as a possible issue.

 

My phone did connect to the MB at some point this morning.  Was out working on our camper and noticed on my phone that I had 5 'bars' (-82 B41) signal out in my yard.  I placed a quick phone call, then hung up.  My phone is now latched back onto the macro tower and not my MB.

 

Really really confused as to how this thing/network/phone is programmed.  I assumed that if I was connected to the magic box, then place a phone call/reboot/cycle airplane mode, the phone would first scan for the last connected system (in this case, the magic box.)  That is apparently wrong.  In this case, for whatever reason, the phone connects to LTE from the macro tower.  I still do not understand at what point my phone decided to switch over to the magic box.  I had already tried a phone reboot as well as cycling airplane mode which I thought would force it to 're-scan' and then grab the Magic Box, but it never grabbed onto it, and still hasn't 30 minutes later.  Makes zero sense to me.  

 

Is anyone with a fully functional magic box able to test the above instance and see what happens?  Ensure you are connected to the Magic Box, then place a phone call, then after the phone call, see how long your phone takes to reconnect to the magic box.  Just wondering if this is common.   :(

 

It's common with all small cells. These units are self optimizing and self configuring just like the bigger and more powerful brethren on light poles or wooden poles. I like to joke around that they take time to "grow" after install because that's how these things work generally. 

 

Once installed in an area, they will slowly learn their RF environment and neighboring sites and handoffs become smoother and quicker. Sometimes it still bugs out and won't reconnect manually with airplane modes or reboots but they always eventually  find their way back to it after a few hours of leaving it alone. Basically it just needs time. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks lilotimz.

 

Just had another call with the support folks, and their indication was that the phone should grab back onto the MB pretty quickly.  He did notice that on my phone line, wifi-calling was still turned on (even though its off on my phone,) so he turned it off on their end as well to see if that made a difference.  Has now been 20 minutes since I got off the phone with him and I am still not connected to the MB.  The MB tech's are supposed to call me back now within 24 hours. :shrug: The support guys I have spoken with so far all seem to think that there may still be something wrong, but they just aren't seeing any errors indicating anything is wrong.  Maybe there isn't actually anything 'wrong' with my unit, but they all still seem to think that my phone should grab onto the thing nearly immediately.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's common with all small cells. These units are self optimizing and self configuring just like the bigger and more powerful brethren on light poles or wooden poles. I like to joke around that they take time to "grow" after install because that's how these things work generally. 

 

Once installed in an area, they will slowly learn their RF environment and neighboring sites and handoffs become smoother and quicker. Sometimes it still bugs out and won't reconnect manually with airplane modes or reboots but they always eventually  find their way back to it after a few hours of leaving it alone. Basically it just needs time. 

 

I had given up on the day that I was installing the MB...I actually had sat in in the spot it currently resides as a last-ditch effort...

Then I just left it, came inside and started playing my Ps4...

I happened to grab my note5 and noticed it said B41 MB on SCP...and I was like "hey, it worked!!"

 

It had sat for probably 2 hours...just searching. It seemed to fix itself from the 20% issue.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks lilotimz.

 

Just had another call with the support folks, and their indication was that the phone should grab back onto the MB pretty quickly.  He did notice that on my phone line, wifi-calling was still turned on (even though its off on my phone,) so he turned it off on their end as well to see if that made a difference.  Has now been 20 minutes since I got off the phone with him and I am still not connected to the MB.  The MB tech's are supposed to call me back now within 24 hours. :shrug: The support guys I have spoken with so far all seem to think that there may still be something wrong, but they just aren't seeing any errors indicating anything is wrong.  Maybe there isn't actually anything 'wrong' with my unit, but they all still seem to think that my phone should grab onto the thing nearly immediately.

 

i wonder if updating the PRL on your iPhone would help? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i wonder if updating the PRL on your iPhone would help? 

 

Per this site, the 'PRL' should have nothing to do with LTE.

 

But to be safe, I have done a total of about 15 ##UPDATE# 's over the past 3 days.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is anyone with a fully functional magic box able to test the above instance and see what happens? Ensure you are connected to the Magic Box, then place a phone call, then after the phone call, see how long your phone takes to reconnect to the magic box. Just wondering if this is common. :(

When I first got my MB it would switch to B26 after a phone call from the macro and then eventually go back to the MB. Now it's instantly back on the MB. You just need to wait for it to finish optimizing and integrating. It could take a few days.

 

 

Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Shaferz have you tried going to a 3g only place in/near your home?

 

To connect for the first couple times you may need to teach the network there is a MB nearby.

 

Yes - I did that based off of a post I saw on reddit (i think?)  It didn't make any difference.

 

And now an hour and 30 minutes after I hung up with the support guy, my phone is now connected to the MB again.  :lol::blink: 

I have noticed, however, that the field test screen on my iphone (which is know is poor) seems to indicate that when I am connected to the MB, under Neighbor Measurements > Neighbor Cells List > 0 > there is nothing that populates there.  However, when I am connected to the macro, values populate.  Will be interesting to see if they populate over the next few days.  Ah well. I must be patient.  :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I should know the answer to this...but in the magic box "relay" status -- are we looking for a higher "CINR" or a lower "CINR"??

 

I'm getting a -121 with -2.1 CINR..

 

What is ideal...lower than that or higher than that?

 

*btw* this is on b25..if that matters.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I should know the answer to this...but in the magic box "relay" status -- are we looking for a higher "CINR" or a lower "CINR"??

 

I'm getting a -121 with -2.1 CINR..

 

What is ideal...lower than that or higher than that?

 

*btw* this is on b25..if that matters.

Carrier to interference noise ratio.

 

In the most basic terms it's a description of the quality of a received LTE signal is. Similar to SINR. The closer to 0 cinr is, the worst the signal quality be.

 

ie a CINR of 15 is far superior to a CINR of 2.

 

Edit: rf is black magix

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Carrier to interference noise ratio.

 

In the most basic terms it's a description of the quality of a received LTE signal is. Similar to SINR. The closer to 0 cinr is, the worst the signal quality be. 

 

ie a CINR of -15 is far superior to a CINR of -2.  

 

No, Tim, just the opposite.  Both are negative CINR:  interference + noise exceeds carrier.  For many airlinks, including LTE, that is poor to unusable.  A 15 dB CINR, on the other hand, would be superior to a 2 dB CINR.

 

AJ

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Folks, if you are getting a negative CINR with the Magic Box, it is not going to work well, if at all.  The Magic Box is not the right solution for your situation.

 

AJ

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Folks, if you are getting a negative CINR with the Magic Box, it is not going to work well, if at all.  The Magic Box is not the right solution for your situation.

 

AJ

 

Mine has been working fine for a week now, with a -3.5 or so CINR and -120db on band 25..

Not to say it will be great forever, but it's doing it for now.

 

~5mbps down, 1.8mbps up

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • large.unreadcontent.png.6ef00db54e758d06

  • gallery_1_23_9202.png

  • Posts

    • So, in summary, here are the options I tested: T-Mobile intl roaming - LTE on SoftBank, routes back to the US (~220ms to 4.2.2.4) IIJ physical SIM - LTE on NTT, local routing Airalo - LTE on SoftBank and KDDI (seems to prefer SoftBank), routed through Singapore (SingTel) Ubigi - 5G on NTT, routed through Singapore (Transatel) US Mobile East Asia roaming - 5G on SoftBank, routed through Singapore (Club SIM) Saily - 5G on NTT, routed through Hong Kong (Truphone)...seems to be poorer routing my1010 - LTE on SoftBank and KDDI (seems to prefer KDDI), routed through Taiwan (Chunghwa Telecom) I wouldn't buy up on the T-Mobile international roaming, but it's a solid fallback. If you have the US Mobile roaming eSIM that's a great option. Otherwise Ubigi, Airalo, or my1010 are all solid options, so get whatever's cheapest. I wouldn't bother trying to find a physical SIM from IIJ...the Japanese IP is nice but there's enough WiFi that you can get a Japanese IP enough for whatever you need, and eSIM flexibility is great (IIJ as eSIM but seems a bit more involved to get it to work).
    • So, the rural part of the journey still has cell service for nearly all the way, usually on B18/19/8 (depending on whether we're talking about KDDI/NTT/SoftBank). I think I saw a bit of B28 and even n28 early on in the trip, though that faded out after a bit. Once we got to where we were going though, KDDI had enough B41 to pull 150+ Mbps, while NTT and SoftBank had B1/B3 IIRC. Cell service was likewise generally fine from Kawaguchiko Station to Tokyo on the express bus to Shinjuku Station, though there were some cases where only low-band LTE was available and capacity seemed to struggle. I also figured out what I was seeing with SoftBank on 40 MHz vs. 100 MHz n77: the 40 MHz blocks are actually inside the n78 band class, but SoftBank advertises them as n77, probably to facilitate NR CA. My phone likely preferred the 40 MHz slices as they're *much* lower-frequency, ~3.4 GHz rather than ~3.9, though of course I did see the 100 MHz slice being used rather often. By contrast, when I got NR on NTT it was either n28 10x10 or, more often, 100 MHz n78. As usual, EMEA bands on my S24 don't CA, so any data speeds I saw were the result of either one LTE carrier or one LTE carrier plus one NR carrier...except for B41 LTE. KDDI seems to have more B41 bandwidth live at this point, so my1010 or Airalo works well for this, and honestly while SoftBank and NTT 5G (in descending order of availability) have 5G that's readily available it may be diminishing returns, particularly given that I still don't know how to, as someone not from Hong Kong, get an eSIM that runs on SoftBank 5G that isn't the USM "comes for free with the unlimited premium package" roaming eSIM (NTT is easy enough thanks to Ubigi). In other news, I was able to borrow someone's Rakuten eSIM and...got LTE with it. 40 Mbps down, 20 Mbps up, 40ms latency to Tokyo while in Tokyo...which isn't any worse than the Japan-based physical SIMs I had used earlier. But not getting n77 or n257 was disappointing, though I had to test the eSIM from one spot rather than bouncing around the city to find somewhere with better reception. It's currently impossible to get a SIM as a foreigner that runs on Rakuten, so that was the best I could do. Also, I know my phone doesn't have all the LTE and 5G bands needed to take full advantage of Japanese networks. My S24 is missing: B21 (1500 MHz) - NTT B11 (1500 MHz) - KDDI, SoftBank B42 (3500 MHz) - NTT, KDDI, SoftBank n79 (4900 MHz) - NTT Of the above, B42/n79 are available on the latest iPhones, though you lose n257, and I'm guessing you're not going to find B11/B21 on a phone sold outside Japan.
    • T-Mobile acquiring SoniqWave's 2.5 GHz spectrum  Another spectrum speculator down! T-Mobile is acquiring all of their BRS/EBS licenses and their leases. Details are lacking but it looks like T-Mobile might be giving them 3.45GHz in exchange in some of the markets where they're acquiring BRS/EBS to sweeten the deal and stay below the spectrum screen. Hopefully NextWave is at the negotiating table with T-Mobile so NYC can finally get access to the full BRS/EBS band as well.  — — — — — Edit: Turns out this is a spectrum swap where T-Mobile is basically giving them DoD spectrum in a bunch of markets in exchange for all of SoniqWave's BRS/EBS. SoniqWave will likely turn around and sell the DoD spectrum to AT&T whenever the FCC removes the 40MHz cap.
    • Maybe. The taller buildings on one side of the street all have Fios access and the NYCHA buildings are surrounded by Verizon macros that have mmWave. I don’t think this site will add much coverage. It’d be better off inside the complex itself.
  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...