Jump to content

Lowest DB for LTE before switching to 3G?


Recommended Posts

What is the lowest DB for LTE before you switch to 3G? 128? 126? 124?

It varies with phone and location.  But, LTE quite often becomes about worthless around a -109 or -110.  You can receive data at those levels, but your transmit signal just does make it to the cell site and be useable. I actually am OK with seeing the LTE drop off and then see the phone lock on to EVDO.  The EVDO will actually work better.

I am now thinking that the HTC EVO LTE phone actually had it right. Just drop off LTE at -109 and forget about it.  Some of the other phones hold on down to -125 or so and it gives you trouble because it is not going to work at those levels.

 

The HTC phone was heavily criticized because it dropped off LTE at a -109 while the other phones held on to the LTE.  This made HTC look bad.  But while the other phones might have held on to the LTE, it did not work.   It is more useful if the phone allows the LTE to drop and gives you EVDO.

  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

It varies with phone and location. But, LTE quite often becomes about worthless around a -109 or -110. You can receive data at those levels, but your transmit signal just does make it to the cell site and be useable. I actually am OK with seeing the LTE drop off and then see the phone lock on to EVDO. The EVDO will actually work better.

I am now thinking that the HTC EVO LTE phone actually had it right. Just drop off LTE at -109 and forget about it. Some of the other phones hold on down to -125 or so and it gives you trouble because it is not going to work at those levels.

 

The HTC phone was heavily criticized because it dropped off LTE at a -109 while the other phones held on to the LTE. This made HTC look bad. But while the other phones might have held on to the LTE, it did not work. It is more useful if the phone allows the LTE to drop and gives you EVDO.

The problem with the Evo was that it was garbage in the RF dept. When the Evo has a -109 and is dropping to 3g, my note II is sitting at - 94 rocking LTE.

 

Sent from my SPH-L900 using Tapatalk 2

 

 

  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What is the lowest DB for LTE before you switch to 3G? 128? 126? 124?

There is no exact answer to this question.  I have seen my evo be able to use lte while connecting at -126db and other times it will drop off at -115 to-120.  I can also say the same for my One and a gs4 that I had for a few days.

  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

My Evo LTE is usuable at above -109. I actually can a -115 signal and getting 2 down. I find that to be better and faster than eHRPD because i always seem to get lower pings as well on lte unless I have a -120 or worse signal. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The GS4 seems to work perfectly fine down to -115 to -120 dBm RSRP, then it drops to EHRPD.

My GS3 will hold to that level too, but the LTE rarely works at this level.   Like I said above, if it ain't capable of handling LTE, it should drop the LTE and give you EVDO.  I get frustrated sometimes when the GS3 has a -115 on LTE but the connection to LTE is pure crapola.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The problem with the Evo was that it was garbage in the RF dept. When the Evo has a -109 and is dropping to 3g, my note II is sitting at - 94 rocking LTE.

 

Sent from my SPH-L900 using Tapatalk 2

You are probably correct with the EVO being garbage in the RF Dept.  I had one for a couple of days and returned it within the 14 day window. I do not have a Note II, but some friends do.  They love em.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My Evo LTE is usuable at above -109. I actually can a -115 signal and getting 2 down. I find that to be better and faster than eHRPD because i always seem to get lower pings as well on lte unless I have a -120 or worse signal. 

You might get 2 down, but I bet you get ZERO up.  Mine would NEVER work at -109 because of a poor transmit signal. I could see 2 down or more on a speed test if I was lucky enough to get my request for a speed test to be recognized.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You might get 2 down, but I bet you get ZERO up. Mine would NEVER work at -109 because of a poor transmit signal. I could see 2 down or more on a speed test if I was lucky enough to get my request for a speed test to be recognized.

To get any down you have to get some upload for the ACK packets.

 

The times when it drops the signal isn't based on numbers. It's based on when it becomes non responsive.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

You might get 2 down, but I bet you get ZERO up.  Mine would NEVER work at -109 because of a poor transmit signal. I could see 2 down or more on a speed test if I was lucky enough to get my request for a speed test to be recognized.

I was able to get 1+ up. 

post-73-0-08134400-1376263736_thumb.png

 

Then I got this. 

post-73-0-13230600-1376263746_thumb.png

 

Then I decided to see what speeds I'd get on EvDo because the tower is 3G accepted too. 

post-73-0-73682800-1376263989_thumb.png

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

To get any down you have to get some upload for the ACK packets.

 

The times when it drops the signal isn't based on numbers. It's based on when it becomes non responsive.

Exactly correct.   Many times, a phone will hold onto a LTE signal and people think they really have something good.  In trying to use it, they find their request for a web site or anything else gets no response.  Eventually the LTE connection totally crashes.  Occasionally it will not crash nor will it work, and that is when you start muttering foul language.  Any EVDO connection is better than a LTE connection that will not work at all.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The highest I can remember seeing on my iPhone had to be somewhere around -109 & -115 I think im not for sure.

 

If that is the *highest* RSRP, then you must be located away from any LTE site in a very weak signal area.

 

;)

 

AJ

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

If that is the *highest* RSRP, then you must be located away from any LTE site in a very weak signal area.

 

;)

 

AJ

Yeah I usually find myself away from the towers which sucks because that means my LTE isn't gonna last long . Traveling about the longest i've been able to maintain an LTE signal before dropping to 3G I have to say about 10 to 20mins :(

 

 

Sent from my iPhone 5 using Tapatalk

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

If that is the *highest* RSRP, then you must be located away from any LTE site in a very weak signal area.

 

;)

 

AJ

Well 800 indoors with voice It's around 80-99.. So hopefully LTE800 will be the same <3

lol and i got -124DB connected to LTE for 5 seconds n my bathroom xD lolol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My primary point is that some of you need to know how to refer correctly to high and low when addressing negative numbers.

 

;)

 

AJ

  • Like 8
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm a math teacher ... don't even get me started on confusion with negative numbers!

 

I feel your pain.  I work with a great many students who get confused by negative numbers.  What I do is show them a number line.  Any value to the left is smaller.  Any value to the right is larger.  If they have any potential, they must understand that exceedingly simple relationship.

 

number_line.gif

 

AJ

  • Like 7
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I feel your pain. I work with a great many students who get confused by negative numbers. What I do is show them a number line. Any value to the left is smaller. Any value to the right is larger. If they have any potential, they must understand that exceedingly simple relationship.

 

number_line.gif

 

AJ

Sometimes even that is hard. I usually use a thermometer as an example. Or an elevator in a tall building.

 

Not knowing how to add or subtract them is worse. You can't learn algebra if you don't know how to do that!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • large.unreadcontent.png.6ef00db54e758d06

  • gallery_1_23_9202.png

  • Posts

    • Luckily, that hasn't arisen in my area where I am, aside from having B14 (well, ALL of AT&T signal) not work at all in Coosa county, Alabama. I wish there was a service for first responders that would go to ANY available carrier, provider, etc..and in the absolute worst case scenario, would give us service. I've been on an ambulance, trying to find an address, and my driver actually had to pull over and we pulled out a map book and tried to find the road using the "old fashioned way".. and that takes valuable time away that sometimes may be vital to someone surviving. BUT, I will say that I've only seen that in Coosa county... both my Tmo and AT&T phones had zero service and I couldn't get GPS, and neither could my driver (VZW service). Maybe satellite will help with that in those times where that occurs.. but that's an extreme example.     Edit to add: Let me add some context to this.. Coosa county isn't regular coverage area for my job.. so it's not a regular thing that we are dispatched to Coosa county.. and actually, there's been a change and that county now has it's own ambulance service that operates.. so the only time we might receive a request is if it's a multiple casualty scenario, or it's a transfer going home from our contracted hospital.  The way that reads above, it may seem like we are just out without some sort of GPS gadget to direct us on where to go, but for the most part, we know our coverage area pretty well. Dispatch can also give us cross streets for reference inside our coverage area (and our home county). Coosa just isn't a regular area for my job to run in. 
    • "Priority" doesn't mean "exclusivity."  When emergency services don't need B14, AT&T can use it for everyone else.  The trade-off is that when it is needed for emergency services, they not only get all of B14, but they have also arranged for priority on the rest of the AT&T network as well.  Beats having spectrum sitting unused most of the time and then not having enough when disaster strikes, as it could be without a partnership with a wireless company like AT&T. - Trip
    • I've wondered if being on the first responder plan has the priority over other 'regular' lines in the same way firstnet does (or, supposed to do with B14...I've seen normal customers on AT&T hit B14 so it's not {specifically} for Firstnet only)...  
    • T-Mobile prices people pay are all over the map. The free lines are key, so take them if ever offered again.  Your priority level would be a key factor for your price.  Only T-Mobile would know the average prices people pay.  Samsung has been offering very good deals at time of new model introductions so I have gone that route for factory unlocked, which allows me to also have a Verizon priority MVNO for when T-Mobile signal fails or I manually override.
    • I also wanted to post a speed test result.. I only do these once in a while from my home area because we are gonna be the last to see changes, like load balancing.  Right now they are digging all over the place for fiber installs, so I'm not sure what the hold-up is on making the upload speed a little more in-line with download speeds, but here is the most recent from my area:   https://www.speedtest.net/my-result/a/10133670525
  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...